Sunday, September 7, 2014

The Jack White/Black Keys Feud In A Nutshell

The White Stripes were way better than the Black Keys. By a lot.

Jack White has recently been doing some impressive stuff in the production world. He has broken records that most folks (myself included) don't really care about. "Lazaretto" broke the record for fastest record release ever (in modern English, that's getting your record from the studio-to-the-shelves really fast). He recorded a live late night show Neil Young performance straight to vinyl. These things are both kinda cool, and I like "Lazaretto" better than anything on his last album. Then you have the Black Keys.
The Black Keys are a good bad who just made their first universally crappy album, Turn Blue. Turn Blue wemt straight to #1 in the US albums chart.
Jack White is a modern icon doing interesting things and he's making no money. The Black Keys are at their musical worst and making lots of money. Jack White had to show his pissed-off-ness somehow.
I've thought the Keys have sounded like the Stripes since 'Brothers' came out. Even the album art was red, white and black. I don't see why people are so shocked at the idea of the Keys "ripping off" the Stripes. I always thought this was obviously underlain knowledge. I myself am shocked that it came from Jack himself. It's unprofessional for this to coming from him. You don't see Paul McCartney and Robert Plant bragging about how much better/more original their music is compared to those that followed them. They sit back and leave it up to you to learn for yourself whose ripping off of who. So despite the truth of what Jack said about the Keys, I'm disappointed in him for doing this.
Let it be known that the Black Keys are not a bad band. I've loved their singles. Their albums aren't too bad. Unlike what Jack claims, they could have definitely existed without the Stripes. Before they sounded like Jack White, they sounded like Jimi Hendrix. Now they sound like 70s coke rock. This isn't necessarily a bad thing. At least it wouldn't be, although "Fever" is a pretty disappointing single for a fan whose waited 3 years for something new. One might say I don't like the new stuff by the Keys.
The White Stripes single-handedly changed the popular world of alternative and garage rock. Looking through their catalog, this may seem ridiculous because all their songs are kinda normal or kinda sound the same. Please just consider that you can distinctly tell Jack White's guitar tone from a mile away. His voice is just as recognizable and Meg's drums were's always indistinguishably playful (and often simple). Strangely dynamic, always fun, classic rock-based riffs, built from the ground-up: The White Stripes.
The Keys are enjoyable, but often try to hard for their own good.
Jack White will be making bank for his new album soon enough, no matter what it sounds like.

Important Music Stuff My Dad Taught Me

In case you haven't noticed, I think music is pretty darn cool. This is definitely something I carried from the collective members of my family. I don't remember any new music that came out between 2002 and 2003 because I became obsessed with classic rock. My dad has taught me a lot of things that have carried on since then. Here are a few that are very much... uh... most like my dad.

--Jazz music is the real deal.   What does it take to get your 15 year old kid into jazz?  Introduce him to Steely freaking Dan. Still today I wish I had a better appreciation for jazz, and I would still skip past 105.5 The River if I was still searching central California radio stations. But I'm a musician and I know that jazz is the hardest style to play. My dad tried explaining this to me when I was younger, but I guess I didn't fully understand. These days I listen to some occasional Miles Davis, John Coltrane & Ornette Colman, but even as a young teenager I was able to love Aja.

--All rock & roll music originated from the blues.   According to my dad, this is why Jimmy Page and Jimi Hendrix were great guitarists; they remember their roots. Eric Clapton once said that new music is so bad because too many artists listen to stuff from his era and refuse to go further back.

--Paul Simon is a genius.   Thinking of my dad, the first bands that come to mind are definitely Styx, Boston and Rush. They were like- The Big 3 for me because my dad loved them more than most people. We even went to a Styx show and a Boston show back in the day. But the Paul Simon thing has really stuck. I remember my dad used to read me books as I went to sleep when I was very little. One night once I was asleep, he secretly switched from reading a book to reading the lyrics to "The Boy In The Bubble." I woke up to it eventually, confused.
I'm 23 now and Paul Simon is among my favorite songwriters. Graceland is a favorite. At a young age, I didn't think the guy who sang about feelin' groovy with a white dude an afro could be all that impressive. But my dad knew he was genius. He told me so.

--Everything old is better than everything new.   This is so freaking true. My older brothers and I were junkies for new "faux-ternative" (thank you Pitchfork) music, but we always loved the "greatest hits" tapes we had for the The Beatles and The Beach Boys. I remember wondering at a young age if old music could be good at all. Turns out, I liked old music the whole time.
My dad (and my mom) always said that music just isn't what it used to be. This is true because most everything that could possibly be done in a studio has already happened (one day I'll write a blog about Kid A). New music can't help it if its unoriginal, but my dad pointed out how poorly some new artists tried.

--AC/DC is pretty lame.   "I've never been impressed by AC/DC." -Wes Hall
I listened to a lot of classic rock radio at one point, which meant I was hearing something from Back In Black at least once a day. It's old. It rocks hard. It's on the radio. Aren't I supposed to like these guys? According to my dad, they are a band without a soul. Even if the solos totally shred, they sound thin and heartless next to any given Zeppelin track. All the songs are about sex. All the riffs sound the same. They're a stupid band.
Mind you, I've decided I'm cool with Bon Scott-era AC/DC, and this criticism comes from a man who had Hall & Oates on vinyl, but it's true. I once said that if the music you're writing isn't personal, it isn't really music. Who knew that my own dad was such a rock & roll skeptic himself?

I learned lots of stuff from Grampa Coach. He got me into lots of great classic bands and did a great job at explaining them to me. If a man's music is what makes a man, my dad kinda rocks.

some thoughts on the music of canada

Nobody cares about what's popular in America. No matter what country you're in, chances are, you're listening to it. Canada is pretty much the same, I guess... but unfortunately, most of what gets recorded in Canada stays in Canada.
I was 7 years old and the first song I ever loved was "One Week" by the Barenaked Ladies. I thought it was funny. Throughout my childhood, my family accumulated the band's complete discography. They had some hits in the US, but they are legitimately heroes of Canadian radio. 1-Because they're Canadian. 2-They think it's funny. These are hilarious reasons for a band to reach nationwide strardom, but this is Canada. Sometimes it's easy to forget what real Canadian music is all about: FREEDOM.
America has this legitimate concept that freedom is to be fought for. Canada believes in freedom too. But they believe it's a mindset; an atmosphere. You live in a country that doesn't nobody hates and you don't hate any other countries. There's plenty of open space. You're born free. Sometimes freedom isn't the sound of a Dixie band playing 1930's John Philip Sousa marches, nor does it sound like 3 Doors Down (but I guess even Canada loves Nickelback). Freedom can be expressed through fresh, unique instrumentation and lyrical exemption. And here we have the clarity, depression and bizarre spirituality of Leonard Cohen. Here we have the jazz-influenced, peace-loving  Joni Mitchell. Here we have the ragged personality and overtly political Neil Young. Here we have the story-telling and beautiful layering of The Band.
I guess there was a dry period for Canadian music. The UK and the US definitely had some musical edge during the 70s and 80s in order to fight their conservative leadership. Meanwhile, Rush was secretly among the most sonic, ambitious prog-rock bands ever. Cowboy Junkies is probably my pick for "most-Canadian-sounding" band from the 1980s, tying in the young genre of alternative rock with their more obvious Canadian folk influences.
I'm not going to say anything about the Tragically Hip or Bryan Adams.
The 1990s was a rebirth decade for Canadian music, at least among Canadians. Walk into a Canadian supermarket and you're bound to hear stuff by Sarah McLachlan, Alanis Morissette or the Barenaked Ladies. McLachlan was the baroque pop version of Joni, Morissette was a hippie, and BnL was (at one point) a good ol' zany Canadian folk band.
The past 15 years have been great for Canada on a critical scale. Arcade Fire brought some unique grandiosity with raw, powerful classical instrumentation. Broken Social Scene used instrumental variety to represent the sorrows and joys of youth, and has since blessed us with great side projects. The New Pornographers were an indie pop band unafraid to cover intellectual topics. The 00s belonged to Montreal and I feel like the 10s will belong to Vancouver.
The past of Canada's music history is unfortunately taken for granted here in the states (On the Beach, The Hissing of Summer Lawns, Music from Big Pink, Songs of Love and Hate, ETC). But the future of Canadian music full of hope and, yes, freedom.

The 90s According to Scott: SONGS

I never thought I'd make this list, but these are probably my 10 Favorite Songs Of The 90s, or The 10 Greatest Songs Of The 90s, or The 10 Most 90s Songs Of The 90s.
Before I list off, you all should know I (like most people who were alive in the 90s) have biases toward alternative rock and against anything that makes you dance. Also, I understand this list is missing plenty of important things: A catchy  Britpop song, So Cal gangsta rap, "Losing My Religion," any given track from Loveless, etc, etc. Anyways. Here it go.

10:CAR  Built To Spill (94)
Doug Martsch is one of my favorite all-time guitarists. The first half of There Is Nothing Wrong With Love is this boy's introduction to how to play some sick guitar on a low budget. PS- he's from Idaho.
9:UNFINISHED SYMPATHY  Massive Attack (91)
I figured I should add some track that represents all the chill trip-hop music from the 90s. This music seems to be everywhere these days. For the Purists and Everyday Joes alike, there's always Massive Attack.
8:YOU GET WHAT YOU GIVE  The New Radicals (98)
I've seen 3 different lists for best 90s songs, all very different from each other. Yet each list has a spot reserved for this song at around #100. Each one! That's because they're all afraid to rank it higher.
7:BITTERSWEET SYMPHONY  The Verve (97)
Personally, I think being from England in the 90s automatically meant you were futuristic and cool and probably wore sunglasses everywhere. Universally, this is a darn good song.
6:1979  The Smashing Pumpkins (95)
#datriff  #goosebumps  #errtime
5:JUICY  The Notorious B.I.G (94)
My favorite 90s hip-hop album is probably Nas's Illmatic. It had a meek, humble personality. This song has all the "started-from-the-bottom" humility, but Biggy shows 0% meekness. When you're Big, you're big.
4:FAKE PLASTIC TREES and/or PARANOID ANDROID  Radiohead (95/97)
Scott! These are 2 totally different songs here from 2 totally different albums! You can only choose 1! Every depressing song for the last 20 years or every band who pretends to sound weird/cool for the last 20 years! Actually... I'll leave this one up to you guys.
3:GOLD SOUNDZ  Pavement (94)
Why isn't this #1? Pavement is my favorite 90s band. This is my favorite song by them. When I saw Pitchfork ranked it #1, I was like- "Whoa, my actual favorite song by my favorite band!" As far as sounding like the 90s, this song captures all the jangly sunshine guitar nostalgia. And, well, Stephen freaking Malkmus.
2:ALL APOLOGIES  Nirvana (93)
Scott, this Nirvana song is ranked really high... and it's not "Smells Like Teen Spirit"... why? Nirvana or no Nirvana, I've always loved this riff. I also love how the lyrics represent an external reality to pain or care... which is actually the Buddhist definition of the state of Nirvana... and what made the 90s fun.
1:LOSER  Beck (94)
In 1998, the Barenaked Ladies got a #1 song in the U.S strictly because they rapped about Chinese chicken. When Beck made "Loser," he wasn't trying to make money. He was from lazy LA, he had an extremely low budget and his music influences ranged from Sonic Youth to classic blues to Bob Dylan to 80s hip-hop. This song is cheap, random, cool and fun. Aside from any grunge band, this is what the 90s sounded like.

My 2 Favorite Songs of 2014 (6 mo's early)

This year, I have an obvious pick for a favorite album. Someone would have to release a masterpiece to beat it out in my book. This album is by Sun Kil Moon and it's called Benji.
So I rarely give songs the kind of treatment I give albums. I like ranking albums on a critical level. More importantly, I can enjoy listening to them. Songs are different. When I hear one, I have to hear at least a couple more to fill emotionally fulfilled. And critically, I rarely say I like one song more than another. My favorite tracks from the last 5 years are "Holocene" by Bon Iver and Destroyer's "Kaputt." After that, I can't rank them. But this is 2014 and I'm 23 years old and at this time in my life, I need Benji. 
I was also going to write about "I Can't Live Without My Mother's Love" (a rugged, 46 year-old man confesses his deep love for his mom) and "Carissa" (capturing the beauty, the realities and the fragility of the death of a loved one), but perhaps I'll save those for another day. To spare your time no longer (and in no ranked order), here are my 2 favorite songs of 2014.
I WATCHED THE FILM THE SONG REMAINS THE SAME
I listened to classic rock and was unaware of any new music at all for a year or 2 in middle school. I wanted to play guitar like Jimmy Page and started playing around 7th grade. Like Mark Kozelek, "I learned to play guitar while everyone else was throwin' around a football." Also like Mark, I too was "always a melancholia kid" and after so many years, I still "cannot shake the melancholia." There's a certain aesthetic for me when I watch a movie I loved when I was younger. It brings back other memories from that age. There's 1 ringing xylophone note played about halfway through the song that shines like a light from an old projector. Throughout its 10:30 length, there's a *ahem* "really pretty" acoustic guitar part that repeatedly cycles like a projector reel. Every verse tells a different story. Zeppelin. His sadness. His love for the music world. Beating up a kid when he was younger. People who have died in his life. The man who gave him a recording contract. ETC. The song outros with a Led Zeppelin III-esque mandolin part. Then it just ends so suddenly; like someone abruptly took the needle off the record player. This is a very sad song. But mostly just beautiful. There are a couple of breaks from the cycling guitar for some heavenly backing vocals reminiscent of the outro to "Going To California." I guess we all have some sad memories. "If anything close to me at all in the world died... to my heart, forever it would be tied. I'll go to my grave with my melancholia & my ghost will echo my sentiments for all eternity."
MICHELINE 
The scariest song on the album just finished and there's on 2 tracks left. Chances are, we've reached the climax, right? "Richard Ramirez Died Today Of Natural Causes" me be Benji's darkest moment, but "Micheline" is the most joyous. Very few songs in the world make me smile like this one. He talks about "feeling somewhere between happy and sad," yet for me, there's no sadness here at all. This song is the sound of children playing in the yard across the street from your porch rocking chair on a summer night. Each verse tells a different story. He starts off telling about the mentally handicap girl who lived down the street from him in his youth. He then reminisces of his old friend Brett who passed away in 1999. The last 2 verses cover fond memories with his grandma, mostly from when he was very young. He recalls the first time he ever saw an ocean, a hummingbird, the movie Benji. Despite some bittersweet moments brought up, everything about this song makes me happy. Like when you cry tears of joy at a small town funeral. He spouts out a lifespan of memories in a *ahem* "very short" 6 minutes. And if it's any consolation, I love the few piano notes added in. Like "Carissa," this song reminds us that life is so fragile and so beautiful. Your grandma deserves a song. So does your mom. And your friend Brett. And the handicapped girl down the road. "She had dreams like everyone else."

Beck Show (stats)

THE CROWD
I was very close and was practically moshing the entire time- not in a moshpit- just trying to stand. We were all just trying to stand and dance and maybe move a little closer. I have never ever ever sweat so much in my entire life. It was blatantly nuts. Beck told us about 3 times to step back and take care of each other. I had drunk guys dancing with me. I single-handedly saved a crowd surfer. I also dropped one. I found some chick's purse. One guy offered me a smoke. Some teenager was yelling "I just smoked pot for the first time!" I was physically covered in other people's bodies, but I wasn't tiny guy. I was a contributing factor to the crew. Despite my closeness, all my pictures sucked. 9.5/10
THE TALENT
Lots of people around me were making of Future Islands lead singer (Sam Herring), but he is possibly the greatest stage performer I have seen in my entire life. He's crying on stage. His sweat changed the color of his shirt by the end of the show. His vocal styles range from David Bowie to Peter Gabriel to Tom Waits to James Hetfield. A beautiful voice. His body covers the entire stage with pure energy and emotion. The actual main act was alright too, I guess. 8.5/10 (perfect 10 for Sam Herring)
THE SETLIST
Beck played 5 songs from his most lazy album, Guero. However, they were a buncha staright-up electronica dance tracks and they sounded freaking great live. Started with "Devil's Haircut." He played "Debra," which I really really wanted him to play secretly. He also played "Minus," which was freaking bonkers. He played 4 songs from his new (and kinda boring) album. But they were actually my favorite tracks from the album. Everyone toked up during "Wave." The prolonged closer "Where It's At" was perfectly fine. (especially since he broke out his harmonica with "One Foot In The Grave" somewhere in the middle). Played nothing from Mutations. He looked confused while the crowd was still going nuts during during "Lost Cause." And screw it, he played "Debra." 10/10
THE CHARACTER
I showed up dressed in my "2-turnables-and-a-microphone" Beck shirt and a bucket hat and fake Kanye-Graduation shades. I tried to reflect his 90s personality. His personality has been a lot more musically boring recently, but that didn't show in the live show. He namely stuck with the bangers. He brought out this vox-speaking, handheld robot that reminded he's probably kept since the Odelay tour. There were a couple of noise-rock breakdowns, which is a refreshing live experience. He's not the same "I'm high and I don't give a f***" guy he used to be. In fact, I think he's sobered up and positive. But I could tell he's got a lot on his mind. He knows people think of him as the king of alternative rock (the guitarist looked like Danger Mouse). He's old, but he's not giving into any categories just yet. 9.5/10
THE ENERGY
Everybody wants to sound loud. Beck can definitely do that. But there were a couple of reminders during the show that he is also "The Enchanting Wizard Of Rythm." "Beercan," "Where It's At," "The New Pollution." The few slow songs he played were atmospheric enough. The fact that a quarter of these songs were from Guero kinda bugged me, but they are very easy to dance to. Also, this entire blog is based off a quote from "Loser."   9.5/10
OVERALL
This was probably the best show I've ever been to.

20 Years of Wilco: SONGS

One of my all-time personal favorite bands is 20 years old this year (for-reals, they started recording in 1994). Their lead singer's releasing his first solo album this week and the band still tours. I thought it'd be appropriate to list my 20 favorite songs by them. Good ol' WILCO.
You must listen to all these songs!

20--'Dawned On Me' (2011)
19--'Sunken Treasure' (1996) This song is the basic format for what makes Wilco "Wilco." Acoustic guitars getting slowly drowned out by noise. This songsmith is a talent that separates these guys from everybody else.  
18--'Born Alone' (2011)
17--'I Must Be High' (1995)
16--'Spiders (Kidsmoke)' (2004)
15--'I Got You (At The End Of The Century)' (1996) This will definitely be played at my wedding. My wife is likely to like it.
14--'Reservations' (2002) This is the most gorgeously freaking depressing song of all time. The perfect album closer.
13--'You & I' (ft. Feist) (2009)
12--'Heavy Metal Drummer' (2002) Listen closely. The song sounds basic, but within its 3 minutes, they actually cram in a ton of instruments.
11--'Can't Stand It' (1999)
10--'Impossible Germany' (2007) #datsolo
9--'She's A Jar' (1999) This song captures what I call "front yard paranoia," a perfected theme on Summerteeth.
8--'Handshake Drugs' (2004)
7--'California Stars' (w/Billy Bragg) (1998) Written by Woody Guthrie!
6--'A Shot In The Arm' (1999)
5--'Jesus, Etc.' (2002) Best song title/Best song 
4--'I Am Trying To Break Your Heart' (2002) So basically, all the top 4 songs have the same format as this one (the "Sunken Treasures" formula).
3--'Misunderstood' (studio and/or live version) (1996/2005) This song is pure Americana.
2--'Via Chicago' (1999) The strings sampling on this track is a miracle.
1--'Poor Places' (2002) As I made this list, I realized I've never heard a song like this one before. It's the climax to my favorite album of all time, Yankee Hotel Foxtrot. Music as layered as this can turn out sloppy, but 'Poor Places' turns out being something beautiful and memorable... And by the end, something very noisy.